The locals know not to drive the Bacchus Marsh Honour of Avenue when storms or strong winds pass through. The old trees are notorious for their exploding branches—the sudden loud crack followed by an explosion of splintering wood, dropping heavy limbs onto the road. Residents regard these dramatic timber cascades as legendary because some survivors recount their narrow escapes, which now exist as local folklore. Longtime resident Margaret Holloway remembers her grandfather saying he sensed a powerful gust when a branch struck his utility truck.
The avenue became off-limits for him whenever storms occurred after that day. However, on a fine day, as cars crawl past the pick-your-own strawberry and fruit orchards, red-rumped grass parrots pop their feathered heads from hollows that have become nesting sites. Their emerald bodies and crimson rumps flash like jewels against the weathered bark. At night, brushtail possums scurry quietly from tree to tree, creating an invisible, bustling life network beneath the canopy. Their soft footsteps and intermittent rustling alert those who are skilled listeners to their existence while demonstrating that a night-active community flourishes unnoticed during commemorative moments.
A Community’s Remarkable Act of Solidarity
Today, the Avenue of Honour in Bacchus Marsh holds far greater significance than its original purpose as a memorial for those who served in the First World War. The avenue was planted by over a thousand community members in August 1918, marking a moment of strong solidarity. It now stands with its Dutch and Huntington Elm trees as living testimonials to each honoured individual. Family members and friends planted trees at once in response to a single bugle call, symbolising their communal unity and shared values. Over one hundred years, the avenue has transformed far beyond its original commemorative purpose.
Historical records reveal the extraordinary logistics behind the planting day. Local nurseries donated hundreds of saplings, and farmers supplied tools and transportation. The town council carefully measured and designated tree planting spots to maintain uniform space and visibility for each tree. The women’s auxiliaries prepared refreshments for over one thousand attendees and arranged long trestle tables along the planting route. When the day arrived, families gathered with photographs and mementos of their loved ones, some placing small keepsakes in the soil alongside the roots—coins, buttons from uniforms, or handwritten notes—creating literal and figurative foundations of memory beneath each tree. It was not just about remembering the dead, trees along the avenue symbolised soldiers who remained in battle and veterans who returned with permanent scars. The avenue acknowledged all forms of sacrifice. The inclusive design of Bacchus Marsh’s memorial set it apart from other memorials of the time because those memorials usually focused solely on fallen soldiers. Newspaper reports described the mood as serious and optimistic as children and elderly participants joined in a shared mission.
Facing Environmental Challenges
Since it first opened, the avenue has struggled with numerous challenges. It first took root with robust Dutch and Huntington Elm trees before facing the destructive threat of Dutch Elm Disease, which attacks elm populations across the globe. Australia remains clear of this disease but needs active monitoring and preventative actions. Elm-leaf beetle infestations persistently threaten these older trees, which suffer from reduced resilience and shorter life spans.
Arborists conduct regular health assessments, deploying sophisticated techniques to monitor the trees’ vitality. Acoustic tomography to detect internal decay without damaging the trees, It’s like an ultrasound for trees, allowing aborists to see inside without harming these living memorials. The examination of soil shows variations in pH balance and nutrient content, and thermal imaging detects stress indicators before they become apparent in human vision. Integrating heritage conservation methods with modern environmental science techniques forms the core of these scientific approaches.
Climate change has also intensified these threats. Extended periods of drought, rising temperatures, and increasingly severe weather events such as storms and high winds have further stressed the mature trees. Adapted to European conditions, the elms struggle with Australia’s increasingly extreme climate patterns. Records show that average summer temperatures along the avenue have risen nearly 2°C since the 1950s, while annual rainfall patterns have become more erratic. During the Millennium Drought (1996-2010), community volunteers established an emergency watering program, with residents “adopting” individual trees to ensure survival.
Rapid urban development raises complex challenges as road expansion and infrastructure projects endanger the fragile root systems of the avenue, which requires meticulous planning and preservation efforts to maintain its stability. Since the 1980s, traffic volumes have increased fourfold, which resulted in exhaust pollution, soil compaction, and collision damage risk. Debate among residents became heated when recent cross-road proposals highlighted the conflict between development pressures and heritage conservation. The local population continues its balancing act between progress and preservation through a compromise consisting of minor road realignment and protective barriers.
Embodied Cultural Memory and Social Identity
According to anthropological theories, the Avenue of Honour represents a living expression of cultural memory by transforming history into a physical experience with living elements. These trees integrate into everyday community life, while traditional monuments typically remain separate entities. The avenue represents what anthropologists call ’emplaced memory, where memory that resides not just in minds or written records, but in the physical landscape and bodily experiences of moving through it.
This embodied quality creates distinctive forms of knowing and remembering. Longtime residents develop what anthropologists term “kinaesthetic knowledge”—understanding derived from bodily movement and sensory experience. They know the avenue not through historical facts alone but through seasonal changes, shifting light patterns, and the physical sensation of walking beneath the canopy. “My grandmother can tell you which tree commemorates her uncle”, recounts resident Eliza Nguyen, “not because she read the plaque, but because she recognises the distinctive bend in the trunk, the particular way light filters through those specific branches in autumn.”
The avenue also functions as what anthropologist Pierre Nora termed a “lieu de mémoire”—a site where collective memory crystallises and cultural identity is maintained. However, crucially, this memory work extends beyond formal commemoration to encompass everyday practices and interactions. Children climbing trees, couples taking wedding photographs, elderly residents sharing benches in dappled shade—these quotidian activities continuously reproduce and transform the avenue’s cultural significance. French anthropologist Michel de Certeau might view these practices as “spatial tactics” through which ordinary people appropriate commemorative space for their purposes.
Knowledge moves between generations through structured learning systems and traditional storytelling methods. Along with recalling its orgnia Elders advise young drivers to avoid falling branches to pass down cultural understandings of nature’s power and their respect for its authority. Holding family picnics beneath ancestor-planted trees enables people to perform continuity rituals that strengthen their social connections and shared identity.
Cultural Evolution of a Commemorative Space
The avenue’s significance has transformed dramatically through an anthropological lens, evolving from a commemoration of war to a multidimensional cultural landscape. Anthropologists note how the community has continuously reinterpreted and reimagined this space according to changing social needs and values. “What we see in Bacchus Marsh is a textbook example of cultural landscapes as dynamic entities”, explains cultural anthropologist Dr. Maya Rodriguez. “The community didn’t freeze the avenue in time as a static war memorial but allowed it to accumulate layers of meaning across generations.”
These layers reveal changing attitudes toward commemoration and nature. The original planting represented early 20th-century approaches to memorialisation—ordered, uniform, and emphasising collective sacrifice. The avenue achieved integration into daily routines by mid-century as its cultural importance grew to shape community identity and collective experience beyond traditional commemoration. The last few decades have exhibited an important transformation where environmental values merge with heritage concerns to embody modern cultural priorities in sustaining and preserving resources.
The transformations become apparent through the rituals and practices associated with the avenue. The initial ceremonies were strictly war commemorative events that maintained a solemn atmosphere. However, modern events now blend multiple cultural components like environmental education and community art installations with storytelling across generations. Evolving practices show how communities keep renegotiating place meaning by embracing lived experiences and cultural expressions.
More-Than-Human Cultural Heritage
Contemporary anthropological approaches recognise that cultural landscapes involve relationships between humans and humans and non-humans. The avenue exemplifies what anthropologist Anna Tsing calls “multispecies entanglement”—a site where human history becomes intertwined with the lives and agencies of other species. The red-rumped parrots nesting in war memorial trees and the brushtail possums creating nocturnal pathways are not merely biological entities but co-creators of the avenue’s cultural significance.
This perspective challenges traditional Western divisions between nature and culture. In the avenue, cultural heritage and natural processes are inseparable—the trees planted as cultural symbols have developed their own biological trajectories and relationships. “The avenue represents what we might call ‘more-than-human heritage,'” environmental anthropologist Dr. Richard Tanner explains. “The community increasingly recognises that cultural value resides not just in human intention and design but in the complex, ongoing relationships between people, trees, wildlife, and place.”
This recognition has profound implications for heritage management. Rather than preserving a static monument, conservation now involves nurturing an evolving set of relationships. When trees age and die, the community negotiates complex questions about replacement and renewal involving cultural continuity and ecological succession. These negotiations reveal changing cultural values around authenticity, integrity, and what constitutes meaningful heritage.
From an anthropological standpoint, the avenue shows how commemorative landscapes transform into cultural innovation and adaptation hubs instead of static memory sites. The avenue is a dynamic cultural space where each generation applies current values to discover new meanings while preserving links to its historical roots. The ongoing reinterpretation and reinvention demonstrates Tim Ingold’s anthropological understanding of landscapes as “taskscapes,” which are environments that evolve through human action and activity.
Cultural Contestation and Negotiation
As with all significant cultural landscapes, the Avenue of Honour has become a site of negotiation and occasional contestation. Anthropological study reveals how different stakeholders—veterans’ groups, environmentalists, local government, heritage professionals, and ordinary residents—bring varying perspectives on what aspects of the avenue should be prioritised and preserved. These negotiations reflect broader cultural tensions around commemoration, development, and environmental responsibility.
Debates about management practices—whether to replace aging trees with identical species or diversify plantings, how to balance commemorative integrity with ecological benefits, whether to incorporate Indigenous perspectives on the landscape—reveal competing cultural values and understandings. These aren’t simply technical decisions, they’re fundamentally about cultural values and how communities negotiate change while maintaining continuity.”
The avenue has also become a site for exploring what anthropologists term “difficult heritage”—aspects of the past that remain uncomfortable or contested. Recent community discussions have addressed the absence of Indigenous perspectives in the original memorial, the changing attitudes toward war commemoration, and questions about whose stories are centred in public memory. These conversations demonstrate how cultural landscapes can facilitate evolving understandings of complex histories.
Cultural Transmission in a Changing World
The Avenue of Honour will continue to be culturally significant as long as it adapts to remain relevant through different social contexts. The endurance of cultural landscapes depends on continuous cultural transmission, which facilitates the transfer of knowledge and practices between generations while allowing these elements to adapt to new situations.
Digital storytelling initiatives, intergenerational oral history projects, and community ceremonies represent emerging forms of cultural transmission that complement traditional commemorative practices. These approaches recognise that cultural significance resides not solely in the physical landscape but in the stories, practices, and relationships that give it meaning.
According to cultural anthropologist Barbara Bender, landscapes remain active because people interact with them through modification and dispute. The Avenue of Honour demonstrates this dynamic quality. The original formal war memorial has now transformed into a complex cultural landscape. Community identity is formed and reformed in this place, where diverse cultural values find expression, and each generation discovers new meanings while maintaining connections to the past.
As longtime resident Maria observes while watching her grandchildren collect fallen elm leaves: “These trees know more about us than we know about them. They’ve seen our weddings and funerals, heard our stories and arguments, watched children grow into elders. They carry our history in their rings, just as we carry their presence in our memories.” This reciprocal relationship between people and place—this continuous co-creation of cultural meaning—remains the avenue’s most profound anthropological significance.
The Living Legacy of the Avenue of Honour
The Avenue of Honour in Bacchus Marsh illustrates how commemorative landscapes transcend their original purposes to become integral to community identity and cultural continuity. What distinguishes this living memorial is its historical significance and ability to facilitate ongoing relationships—between past and present, between human and non-human agents, and between commemoration and everyday life.
As we look to the future of such cultural landscapes, the avenue offers valuable insights for heritage practice and community stewardship. It demonstrates that effective conservation requires attention to physical preservation and the maintenance of meaningful relationships and cultural processes. The most successful approaches will be those that recognise heritage as fundamentally dynamic—not a static artifact to be frozen in time, but a living system that requires space for adaptation and evolution.
The avenue challenges us to move beyond conventional dichotomies of natural versus cultural heritage toward more integrated understandings that acknowledge the inseparability of human memory and natural processes. It invites us to consider how communities might sustain connections to significant places while allowing those places to change and develop in response to new circumstances and values.
Perhaps most importantly, the Avenue of Honour reminds us that cultural landscapes derive their most profound significance not from official designations or expert valuations but from their continued ability to matter in the lives of communities. As long as residents continue to drive carefully during storms, notice the flash of parrots among elm branches, tell stories beneath the canopy, and negotiate the avenue’s future with care and attention, this remarkable cultural landscape will continue to thrive as a site where memory is not merely preserved but actively created.
In the century since its planting, the Avenue of Honour has demonstrated that the most enduring memorials are not those that remain unchanged but those that continue to change with us—living entities that grow, adapt, and evolve while maintaining the essential connections between people, place, and memory that give meaning to our collective experience.
References
Bender, B. (2002). Time and landscape. Current Anthropology, 43(S4), S103-S112.
Byrne, D., & Goodall, H. (2013). Placemaking and transnationalism: Recent migrants and a national park in Sydney, Australia. Parks, 19(1), 63-72.
Casey, E. S. (2001). Between geography and philosophy: What does being in the place world mean? Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 91(4), 683-693.
de Certeau, M. (1984). The practice of everyday life. University of California Press.
Dicks, B. (2000). heritage, place and community. University of Wales Press.
Harrison, R. (2015). Beyond “natural” and “cultural” heritage: Toward an ontological politics of heritage in the age of Anthropocene. Heritage & Society, 8(1), 24-42.
Ingold, T. (1993). The temporality of the landscape. World Archaeology, 25(2), 152-174.
Macdonald, S. (2009). Complex Heritage: Negotiating the Nazi past in Nuremberg and beyond. Routledge.
Nora, P. (1989). Between memory and history: Les lieux de mémoire. Representations, (26), 7-24.
Smith, L. (2006). Uses of heritage. Routledge.
Tsing, A. L. (2015). The mushroom at the end of the world: On the possibility of life in capitalist ruins. Princeton University Press.
Waterton, E., & Watson, S. (2015). The Palgrave handbook of contemporary heritage research. Palgrave Macmillan.
Weiss, L. (2007). Heritage-making and political identity. Journal of Social Archaeology, 7(3), 413-431.
Wylie, J. (2007). Landscape. Routledge.
